What Makes a YouTube Video Idea 'Great'? (Beyond Just Viral Potential)

Ready to get your next 10,000 subscribers?

Join thousands of creators who use Subscribr to create faster, better YouTube videos.

Free trial No credit card required

What Makes a YouTube Video Idea 'Great'? (Beyond Just Viral Potential)

As an intermediate creator, you've likely felt the pressure to constantly come up with video ideas that will "go viral." It's a common pain point: uncertainty about what your audience really wants and a struggle to make your content stand out in a crowded space. But what if chasing fleeting virality isn't the path to sustainable growth?

The truth is, a truly great YouTube video idea is about much more than just racking up views. It's the bedrock of a thriving channel, connecting with your audience, building a strong brand, and setting you up for long-term monetization. So, how do you know if your video idea is good, and what type of content does well on YouTube? It starts with understanding the core qualities of a great concept.

Beyond the Hype: Defining a Great Video Idea

A great video idea isn't just a topic; it's the intersection of a compelling subject and a format that engages your specific audience. Based on insights from YouTube strategists, truly impactful ideas share several key characteristics:

1. It Excites You: This might sound simple, but passion is palpable. If you're not genuinely excited about an idea, it will show in your delivery and likely won't resonate with viewers. Creating content you're passionate about fuels consistency and authenticity.
2. It's Feasible: A grand, impossible idea stays just an idea. Can you realistically execute this concept with your current resources, skills, and time? Be honest about what you can achieve.
3. There's Evidence of View Potential: While not every video needs to be a guaranteed hit, a great idea often has some basis in what has worked before. This could be similar past videos on your channel that performed well, or successful concepts on other channels in your niche. Tools like Subscribr's Channel and Video Intelligence can help you analyze what's performing well in your space.
4. It Has Clickable Packaging Potential: Can you envision a compelling title and thumbnail that makes someone have to click? The best idea in the world won't get seen if the packaging is weak. This requires thinking visually and crafting curiosity.
5. It Appeals to Your Audience: This is perhaps the most critical element. A great idea speaks directly to the needs, interests, or curiosities of your target viewers, ideally extending beyond just your core subscribers to attract casual and new viewers too.

Channels that grow successfully often take what their core audience loves and transform it into bigger ideas with broader appeal. For example, a channel focused on educational geography, like @HGPworld (31.5K subscribers), finds success by covering specific geographical features, countries, or geopolitical topics in an accessible format, appealing to both existing subscribers and new viewers interested in learning about a particular place.

The Psychology of Content: Making Videos People Want to Watch

Understanding why people watch YouTube is fundamental to generating great ideas. It boils down to fulfilling core viewer motivations. People typically watch YouTube to:

• Solve a Problem: They need to learn how to do something. Tutorials and how-to guides fall into this category.
• Be Entertained: They want to laugh, be amazed, escape, or experience something new.
• Be Educated: They want to learn about a topic in depth. Documentaries, explainers, and informational videos fit here.
• Connect & Belong: They want to feel part of a community or connect with a personality they admire. Vlogs, community Q&As, and live streams serve this need.

A great video idea taps into one or more of these motivations. For intermediate creators struggling with uncertainty about audience preferences, focusing on solving problems or educating within your niche is a powerful approach.

Consider successful tutorial videos found through our research:

• "How to Use Notion - Beginners Tutorial" (185K views, 8.1 Outlier Score) by @TheCuttingEdgeSchool
• "DaVinci Resolve - COMPLETE Tutorial for Beginners!" (3.3M views, 3.9 Outlier Score) by @PrimalVideo

These videos work because they identify a clear problem or need ("How do I use Notion?", "How do I edit video as a beginner?", "How can I turn text into video quickly?") and promise a direct solution. The high outlier scores indicate they performed significantly better than the channel's average, suggesting the idea itself resonated strongly with the audience at that time.

Subscribr's Audience Persona generation can help you visualize and understand your target viewer's needs and pain points, making it easier to brainstorm ideas that genuinely resonate.

Systematic Idea Generation & Validation

Instead of waiting for inspiration to strike, successful creators employ systematic approaches to generating and validating ideas. Great ideas often fall into a few categories:

1. Searchable Ideas: These directly address questions people are actively typing into YouTube search (e.g., "how to [do something]"). They tend to be evergreen and build consistent viewership over time. Channels like @crackconcepts (135K subscribers), which focuses on SQL and DBMS tutorials, likely leverage searchable topics to attract viewers looking for specific technical help.
2. Trending Ideas: These capitalize on current popular topics or events. Timing is crucial – you need to ride the wave at the right moment. This requires staying informed about what's happening in your niche and the world.
3. Unique or Noteworthy Ideas: These spark curiosity and interest regardless of trends or search volume. They often involve extreme concepts, unprecedented feats, or highly original takes on a topic.

A systematic approach involves exploring these categories, brainstorming variations, and then validating potential ideas. Before you spend hours filming and editing, do some quick research. Use Subscribr's Research Assistant to import YouTube transcripts from similar videos or analyze web pages related to your topic. Look at the comments on competitor videos – what questions are still unanswered? What problems weren't fully solved? This helps ensure there's actual demand and that you can add unique value (addressing the "struggling to make content stand out" pain point).

Content Differentiation & Your Unique Value Proposition (UVP)

In a crowded niche, your video ideas need to help you stand out. This is where your Unique Value Proposition (UVP) comes in – what makes your channel and your content different and better for a specific viewer?

A great idea leverages your UVP. If you're a cooking channel that focuses on budget-friendly meals for students, a great idea might be "5 Meals Under $5 for College Dorms." This isn't just a cooking video; it's a budget-friendly, student-specific cooking video, directly aligning with your UVP and targeting a specific audience need.

Channels like @StudyPrideCorner (138K subscribers), which offers educational essays and facts in English and Hindi, or @easyaapadikalam (175K subscribers) for Maths and Chemistry shortcuts, succeed partly because they provide specific educational content tailored to particular audiences and learning needs, differentiating themselves within the broader educational landscape.

Your ideas should feel authentic to your voice and brand. Subscribr's Voice Profiles can help you define and maintain a consistent tone and style across your content, ensuring your ideas are presented in a way that feels uniquely you.

Evaluating Your Ideas: A Practical Framework

Here's a simple framework, inspired by strategic thinking, to evaluate your potential video ideas:

1. The Excitement Test: On a scale of 1-10, how excited are you to make this video? (Aim for 7+)
2. The Feasibility Check: Do you have the skills, time, and resources to produce this video well?
3. The Audience Resonance Score: Based on your knowledge of your audience and research, how likely is this idea to strongly appeal to your target viewer? (Consider their needs, interests, and motivations).
4. The Packaging Potential: Can you come up with at least 3 distinct, highly clickable title and thumbnail concepts for this video?
5. The Value Proposition Alignment: Does this idea fit your channel's niche and leverage your unique strengths or perspective?
6. The View Potential Indicator: Is there any evidence (your past videos, other channels' videos) that a significant number of people are interested in this topic/format combination?

Running your ideas through this framework can help you move from simply brainstorming topics to identifying truly great concepts that have the potential to perform well and contribute to your channel's growth.

Monetization: Great Ideas Build a Foundation

Focusing on creating great ideas that resonate deeply with your audience is the most sustainable path to monetization. While viral hits can provide short-term boosts, a loyal, engaged audience built on consistent, valuable content is crucial for long-term revenue streams.

When you consistently deliver content that fulfills your audience's needs and aligns with your UVP, you build trust and authority. This makes viewers more likely to watch more of your videos (increasing ad revenue), support you through memberships or merchandise, and respond to sponsored content because they trust your recommendations. A strong brand built on great ideas also makes you more attractive to potential sponsors.

Subscribr's focus on audience-centric content development and strategic planning directly supports building this loyal audience, which is essential for maximizing monetization opportunities beyond just ad views.

Tools & Resources: Powering Your Idea Generation

Developing great video ideas systematically is significantly easier with the right tools. Subscribr is designed to support creators at every stage of this process:

• Channel and Video Intelligence: Analyze your own channel's performance and competitor videos to identify patterns, popular topics, and video formats that resonate. Use Outlier Scores to pinpoint videos that significantly exceeded expectations, then analyze why that idea worked.
• Audience Personas: Gain a deeper understanding of your target audience's demographics, interests, and pain points to tailor your ideas directly to their needs.
• Research Assistant: Quickly gather information by importing content from web pages or analyzing YouTube video transcripts directly within the platform. This helps you validate ideas and ensure you're adding unique value.
• AI Script Writer & Frame Development: Once you have a promising idea, Subscribr helps you structure your thoughts, define your content angle, and build a compelling script outline, ensuring your great idea translates into a well-executed video.

By leveraging these tools, you can move from guessing what might work to making data-informed decisions about which ideas have the greatest potential for your channel and your audience.

Conclusion

Knowing how to make videos people want to watch starts with shifting your focus from the elusive chase for virality to the consistent pursuit of great ideas. A great idea excites you, is feasible, has evidence of potential, can be packaged compellingly, and, most importantly, deeply resonates with your target audience by fulfilling their core motivations.

By adopting a systematic approach to idea generation, validating your concepts with research, understanding your unique value proposition, and leveraging tools like Subscribr to understand your audience and analyze what's working, you can overcome the uncertainty and create content that not only stands out but also builds a loyal community and drives sustainable channel growth. Stop chasing views and start creating value – that's the hallmark of a truly great YouTube video idea.