Ready to get your next 10,000 subscribers?
Join thousands of creators who use Subscribr to create faster, better YouTube videos.
How to Handle That First Negative Comment on Your New YouTube Channel (Without Freaking Out)
Getting your first few subscribers is exciting. Sharing your passion with the world feels amazing. Then it happens. That first negative comment. Maybe it's mean, maybe it's just dismissive, but it stings. If you're a new YouTuber, putting yourself out there can feel vulnerable, and criticism can trigger fears of judgment, failure, or just the awkwardness of being on camera.
It's completely normal to feel hurt or discouraged by negativity, especially when your channel is just starting out and every view and comment feels so personal. But learning to handle negative comments constructively is a crucial skill for long-term success and building a positive community on YouTube. It's a key part of developing the resilience you need to keep creating and eventually monetize your passion.
So, how do you navigate this common hurdle? Let's break it down.
Why Do People Leave Mean Comments on YouTube?
Before you take a negative comment too personally, it helps to understand where it might be coming from. Often, the people leaving mean comments aren't doing it because of a genuine flaw in your content or you as a person.
- Anonymity: The internet provides a shield. People will say things online from behind a screen that they would never say to your face. They might be using fake accounts or feel emboldened by the distance.
- Their Own Issues: Sometimes, negativity is a projection of the commenter's own unhappiness, insecurities, or frustrations. As one strategy source put it, often "the most critical commenters are those who are themselves unhappy or underachieving."
- Misunderstanding or Different Perspectives: They might genuinely misunderstand your point or simply have a different opinion. While this isn't necessarily "mean," it can come across negatively if phrased poorly.
- Trolling: Some people simply enjoy provoking a reaction. They deliberately post inflammatory or off-topic comments to get attention and cause disruption.
- Disagreement with Success: As your channel grows, even just a little, you might attract criticism simply because you are putting yourself out there and gaining traction. As the saying goes, "the only way to avoid criticism is to say nothing, do nothing, be nothing." Receiving criticism can actually be a sign you're making an impact.
Recognizing these potential sources can help you depersonalize the comment and not internalize it as a reflection of your worth.
Should I Delete Negative Comments on YouTube?
This is one of the most common questions new creators ask. There's no single "right" answer, but here's a strategic approach recommended by experienced creators:
- Pure Hate/Insults/Spam: Delete Immediately. Comments that contain profanity, personal attacks, hate speech, spam, or are completely off-topic and disruptive should be removed without hesitation. These comments don't add value, harm your community environment, and can even violate YouTube's Community Guidelines. You can use YouTube's built-in moderation tools to hold potentially inappropriate comments for review or filter specific words.
- Constructive Criticism: Consider Keeping and Responding (Carefully). Sometimes, a negative comment might contain valid feedback disguised in a harsh tone. For example, someone might complain about your audio quality. If this is feedback you're hearing from multiple people, it might be something worth addressing. If a comment offers genuine, polite disagreement or points out a factual error, you could choose to leave it and respond professionally. This shows you are open to feedback. However, if the tone is unnecessarily mean, even if there's a kernel of truth, you are not obligated to keep it.
- Simply Negative/Disagreeable (But Not Hateful): Evaluate. This is where it gets nuanced. If a comment is just someone saying they didn't like the video or disagree, but it's not hateful or abusive, you have options. You can:
- Ignore it: Often the best approach. Engaging gives the comment more visibility and energy.
- Hide the user from the channel: This prevents them from commenting again, and their existing comments become invisible to others. This is less confrontational than blocking but still removes the negativity.
- Respond briefly and professionally: Address the specific point without getting defensive. "Thanks for your feedback" is often enough. Avoid getting drawn into an argument.
Key Takeaway: You are the curator of your comment section. Your primary goal is to foster a positive and safe space for your community. Don't feel pressured to keep comments that detract from that. As one strategy suggests, focus on maintaining a positive environment for the viewers who do appreciate your work.
How Do YouTubers Deal with Hate Comments? (Developing Thick Skin)
Dealing with hate comments and negativity is an inevitable part of being a public creator. Learning to manage the emotional impact is crucial for your mental well-being and the longevity of your channel. Here's how successful YouTubers approach it:
- Expect It: Prepare yourself mentally. As your channel grows, you will receive negative comments. Knowing this upfront can lessen the shock when it happens.
- Don't Take It Personally: This is easier said than done, but it's vital. Remind yourself that the comment is often about the commenter, not you. It's just text on a screen from someone who doesn't know you or your effort.
- Focus on the Positive: Actively seek out and engage with positive comments. These are the people who support you and your content. One strategy source suggests having a team member filter comments, flagging positive ones for you and providing a general sentiment summary of the rest. While you might not have a team yet as a new creator, you can practice this yourself by consciously seeking out and focusing on the supportive feedback.
- Look at the Data: Negative comments can feel louder than positive ones ("haters math"). Check your YouTube Studio analytics. Look at your like-to-dislike ratio. If it's overwhelmingly positive (e.g., 95%+ likes), those few negative comments are truly a tiny minority. This objective data provides valuable perspective.
- Find the Humor: Sometimes, negative comments are so absurd they're almost funny. Sharing them with a friend or family member who has a good sense of humor can help you laugh it off and lighten the situation.
- Remember Your 'Why': Why did you start your channel? What impact do you want to make? Focus on your original purpose and the value you provide to the people who do appreciate your content. Don't let negativity derail your mission.
- Set Boundaries: You have the power to moderate your space. Delete hateful comments, hide users, or block them if necessary. You don't owe anyone access to your channel if they are being abusive.
- Learn (If Possible): While filtering out pure hate, be open to spotting trends in feedback. If multiple comments, even negative ones, point to the same issue, it might be constructive criticism you can learn from. However, don't overemphasize isolated negative remarks.
Developing a "thick skin but keep a soft heart" is the goal. Be resilient against baseless negativity while remaining open to genuine feedback that can help you improve.
Building Resilience and a Positive Community
Handling negative comments isn't just about damage control; it's about building resilience and fostering the kind of community that supports your growth and eventual monetization.
- Engage with Positivity: Make an effort to reply to positive comments. Thank people for watching, answer questions, and create conversation. This shows appreciation and encourages more positive interaction.
- Set Community Guidelines: You can set expectations for behavior in your comment section. Pin a comment outlining your rules for respectful discussion.
- Use Moderation Tools: Utilize YouTube's features to automatically hold comments with certain words or from certain users for review. This saves you time and shields you from some of the negativity upfront.
- Focus on Your Ideal Audience: Remember who you are making content FOR. These are the people whose opinions truly matter and who will form the core of your community.
- Don't Feed the Trolls: Trolls thrive on attention and emotional reactions. The fastest way to disarm them is to ignore them completely or simply delete their comment without a response.
Building a channel requires courage, especially when you're just starting out and feeling vulnerable. Negative comments are a test, but they don't define you or your content. By understanding where negativity comes from, using moderation tools effectively, and focusing on building a positive community, you can navigate this challenge and continue to grow your channel with resilience.
Remember, even a single negative comment can feel overwhelming, but it's crucial to look at the bigger picture – the positive engagement, the viewers who appreciate your work, and the valuable content you are creating. Stay true to your vision, keep creating, and don't let a few negative voices silence your unique contribution to YouTube.
P.S. If you're looking for tools to help you stay productive on your YouTube journey, don't forget to check out Subscribr's YouTube AI platform.
