Ready to get your next 10,000 subscribers?
Join thousands of creators who use Subscribr to create faster, better YouTube videos.
YouTube vs. Other Platforms: Where is Monetization Best for Creators?
As an early-stage creator who has joined the YouTube Partner Program (YPP), you've unlocked the door to monetization. But the digital landscape is vast, and platforms like TikTok, Instagram, Twitch, and Patreon also promise earning potential. This can leave you feeling uncertain about where to invest your limited time and confused by the different ways each platform pays creators.
Understanding the nuances of monetization across these platforms is crucial for building a sustainable media business and Diversifying your income streams beyond just AdSense. It's not about abandoning YouTube, but strategically evaluating where your content and audience can generate the most revenue, and how these platforms can complement each other.
Let's break down the monetization landscape in 2025 and help you make informed decisions.
The Current Creator Monetization Landscape in 2025
The creator economy is booming, valued at over $127 billion and projected to grow significantly. This growth means more opportunities, but also increased competition and complexity. While platform-specific ad revenue exists, relying solely on it is becoming less sustainable due to fluctuating payouts and algorithm changes.
Diversifying your income has shifted from a nice-to-have to a necessity. According to recent data, nearly 70% of creators use brand deals as a primary income source, highlighting the importance of looking beyond platform-native monetization.
When comparing platforms, it's not just about which one could pay the most for a viral hit, but which offers the most stable and diverse opportunities for your specific audience and content style as you grow.
Recent research indicates that in 2025, YouTube is still considered the top platform for generating income by the largest percentage of creators (28.6%), followed by TikTok (18.3%), Facebook (16.5%), and Instagram (11.8%). While YouTube leads in creator perception of income potential, it's important to look at how money is made on each platform.
How Significant is YouTube Monetization Compared to Other Platforms?
YouTube remains a powerhouse for creator monetization, primarily through AdSense revenue on long-form videos. The ability to earn based on watch time provides a level of predictability once you reach a certain scale. However, direct ad revenue from newer formats like YouTube Shorts is currently much lower per view compared to traditional long-form content. This means Shorts are powerful for reach and discovery, but less so for direct monetization right now.
Beyond AdSense, YouTube offers Channel Memberships, Super Chats, Super Stickers, and the ability to sell merchandise, providing diverse ways for your most engaged fans to support you directly.
Compared to other platforms:
- TikTok & Instagram: These platforms excel in short-form content and discovery. While they have creator funds and ad revenue sharing (like Instagram Reels Play bonuses, though these can vary significantly), the per-view payout is generally lower than YouTube's long-form video. Their strength lies in driving massive reach, which can then be leveraged for other monetization methods like brand deals, affiliate marketing, or driving traffic to other platforms (like YouTube or a personal store).
- Twitch: This platform is centered around live streaming, particularly gaming, but expanding into other niches. Monetization is heavily reliant on direct audience support through subscriptions, bits (donations), and ads run during streams. It fosters deep community connection, which can translate into higher per-fan revenue, but requires a significant time investment in live content.
- Patreon: Unlike the others, Patreon is purely a membership platform. Creators offer exclusive content or perks to subscribers who pay a recurring fee. It's not a discovery platform but an excellent tool for nurturing your most dedicated audience and building a stable income stream independent of platform algorithms.
For an early-stage creator in the YPP, YouTube provides a foundational income through AdSense on long-form content, while Shorts can rapidly build audience. The key is to see YouTube as your primary hub for deeper content and community, and other platforms as potential feeders or supplementary income sources.
Which Platform Pays Creators the Most?
This is a complex question with no single answer, as it heavily depends on the type of monetization and the creator's strategy.
- Ad Revenue: YouTube generally offers the highest ad revenue per thousand views (CPM) for long-form content compared to the per-view payouts on TikTok or Instagram's short-form content.
- Brand Deals: Brand partnerships can be incredibly lucrative across all platforms, but rates vary massively based on audience size, engagement, niche, and the creator's negotiation skills. Micro-influencers (10k-50k followers) can command significant fees per post or video. Platforms with high engagement rates, even with smaller audiences, can be very attractive to brands.
- Direct Fan Support (Subscriptions/Donations): Platforms like Twitch and Patreon are built around direct fan payments and can be the most profitable per engaged follower. YouTube Memberships also fall into this category.
- Selling Products/Services: Creating and selling your own digital or physical products, courses, or services can yield the highest profit margins, and your social media platforms act as marketing channels.
While a viral TikTok might pay a few hundred dollars from a creator fund payout, that same reach on YouTube could potentially generate more AdSense over time as viewers discover and watch related videos. More importantly, a large audience on any platform can be leveraged for high-paying brand deals or sales of your own products.
For instance, a channel like @sanderstage (93.5k subscribers) focusing on making money online might see decent AdSense, but their real income potential lies in selling courses or services related to their expertise, using YouTube as the primary marketing channel. Similarly, channels focused on digital products like @stanforcreators (9.9k subscribers) or AI tools like @createwithai7070 (16.8k subscribers) can build significant businesses by selling their knowledge or tools, even with relatively smaller audiences compared to entertainment channels.
The research shows that only a tiny fraction (2%) of creators make over $1 million annually, usually requiring millions of followers. However, many creators with much smaller, engaged audiences (e.g., 10k-50k subscribers) are building six-figure businesses through diversified income streams.
Should I Focus on YouTube or Other Platforms for Income?
For early-stage creators already in the YPP, YouTube should likely remain your primary focus for content creation, but strategically utilize other platforms for reach and diversification.
- Establish Your Core on YouTube: Continue creating high-quality, long-form content that resonates with your niche audience. This builds watch time for AdSense and provides valuable, in-depth content that attracts dedicated subscribers. Use YouTube Shorts strategically for discoverability and driving traffic to your long-form videos, understanding that Shorts' direct monetization is currently limited.
- Leverage Other Platforms for Reach and Audience Building: Use TikTok, Instagram Reels, and other short-form platforms to create quick, engaging clips that tease your YouTube content or showcase your personality. These platforms are designed for rapid distribution and can introduce your brand to new audiences who might then subscribe to your YouTube channel for more in-depth value.
- Diversify Income Streams Early: Don't wait for massive subscriber counts to explore other monetization methods.
- Affiliate Marketing: Promote products or services you genuinely use in your videos and social posts.
- Brand Deals: As your audience grows, even if it's niche, brands will be interested in sponsored content. Channels like those found in our search focusing on specific topics like "AI Business" or "Online Business" can attract relevant brand partnerships.
- Fan Funding: Offer exclusive content or community access through YouTube Memberships or a platform like Patreon. This builds a stable income stream from your most loyal fans.
- Sell Your Own Products/Services: Turn your expertise into digital products (ebooks, courses, templates) or offer services (coaching, consulting, freelance work). This is where you often have the highest earning potential per customer.
- Streaming: Platforms like Twitch or YouTube Live allow for real-time engagement and fan donations.
Think of your online presence as a central hub (likely YouTube) with spokes reaching out to other platforms. Each platform serves a different purpose – YouTube for deep content and core monetization, short-form platforms for wide reach, Patreon for dedicated community support, etc.
Building a sustainable media business isn't about finding the one platform that pays the most, but intelligently combining the strengths of multiple platforms and monetization methods to create a robust income structure that isn't solely reliant on any single source or algorithm change. It's about owning your audience relationships and creating value they are willing to pay for directly, alongside platform-generated revenue.
Tools like Subscribr can assist in this multi-platform strategy. For instance, Subscribr's Channel Intelligence system can help you analyze your performance across different content formats (including Shorts vs. long-form), identifying what resonates most with your audience on YouTube. Its Research Assistant can help you research potential product or service ideas based on what your audience is asking about. By understanding your audience's needs and leveraging insights from your existing content performance, you can make strategic decisions about which monetization methods to prioritize and how to use each platform effectively to support your overall business goals.
Building a Sustainable Media Business Through Diversification
The most successful creators don't rely on a single income stream. They build a business around their personal brand and audience. This involves treating your content creation like a startup, constantly evaluating opportunities and building assets that you control (like an email list or direct membership).
Consider the content opportunity of comparing YouTube Shorts vs. Long-Form monetization, expanded to platform comparison. While Shorts might not pay much directly, they can bring thousands of new eyes to your channel. These new viewers might then watch your long-form videos (generating AdSense), join your memberships, or buy your products.
Your strategy should be to maximize revenue per fan, not just per view. A fan who buys your course or joins your membership is often worth far more than the ad revenue from their views.
By focusing on building deep connections with your audience on your primary platform (YouTube), using other platforms for discovery, and layering multiple income streams, you create a more stable and profitable future for your creator business. This approach directly addresses the pain points of monetization uncertainty and confusion by providing a clear path towards financial stability and independence.
