YouTube Shorts vs. Long Videos: What's Best for New Channels?

Ready to get your next 10,000 subscribers?

Join thousands of creators who use Subscribr to create faster, better YouTube videos.

Free trial No credit card required

YouTube Shorts vs. Long Videos: What's Best for New Channels?

Starting a YouTube channel is exciting, but let's be honest – it can also feel overwhelming. You've got ideas buzzing, but where do you even begin? What kind of videos should you make first? Should you jump on the Shorts trend, or stick to traditional long-form content? This is a question every aspiring creator grapples with, and getting the answer right can significantly impact your channel's early growth and future success.

Many new creators face the pain points of being overwhelmed by choices and struggling to develop a sustainable content plan. Choosing your primary video format is a fundamental part of building that plan. There's no single "right" answer for everyone, but by understanding the strengths and weaknesses of both YouTube Shorts and long-form videos, you can make an informed decision that aligns with your goals and capacity.

Let's break down the great debate: Shorts versus Long Form for brand new channels.

YouTube Shorts: The Fast Track to Discoverability?

YouTube Shorts, videos 60 seconds or less formatted vertically, exploded onto the scene and quickly became a powerful tool for discoverability. For new channels, they offer several compelling advantages:

• Lower Barrier to Entry: Shorts are generally much easier and faster to produce than long-form videos. You don't need complex editing or expensive equipment to get started. Often, a smartphone is all you need. This lower production overhead makes it easier to experiment frequently and learn what resonates with viewers without investing massive amounts of time and resources into each video.
• Rapid Audience Building: Shorts live in a dedicated feed, separate from the main YouTube browse and watch pages. This feed-based consumption can lead to rapid bursts of views and subscriber growth, sometimes with just a few successful videos. If your primary goal is to gain subscribers quickly, Shorts can be an effective path.
• Quick Feedback Loop: Because they are easy to produce and consume, you can upload Shorts frequently (even daily) and get fast feedback on what topics, hooks, and styles are working. This allows for rapid iteration and learning.

However, relying solely on Shorts, or starting with Shorts with the intention of easily transitioning viewers to long-form, comes with significant challenges:

• Low Monetization: While YouTube's Shorts monetization is evolving, the revenue per 1,000 views (RPM) is significantly lower compared to long-form videos, which benefit from pre-roll, mid-roll, and post-roll ads. If your goal is to generate significant income quickly through AdSense, a Shorts-only strategy will likely be disappointing.
• Audience Mismatch: This is perhaps the most critical challenge. Viewers who primarily consume Shorts often have a different viewing habit and attention span than those who watch long-form content. They are often in a "doom-scrolling" mindset, looking for quick entertainment or information bites (around 30 seconds). Building a large subscriber base from Shorts does not guarantee that those subscribers will watch your 8-10 minute long-form videos. Attempting to convert a Shorts audience to long-form often results in low view counts on your longer content, which can actually hurt your channel's performance in the algorithm.
• Content Depth Limitations: By their nature, Shorts are limited in how much depth or nuance they can provide. If your niche requires detailed explanations, tutorials, or storytelling, you'll quickly hit a ceiling with what you can accomplish in 60 seconds.

Can you grow a YouTube channel with only Shorts? Yes, you absolutely can grow a large subscriber base using only Shorts. Many channels have achieved hundreds of thousands or even millions of subscribers this way. However, growing a business or achieving sustainable full-time income solely through Shorts monetization is much harder due to the low RPM. If your definition of "grow" is primarily subscriber count, Shorts is viable. If it's building a long-term, monetizable channel, Shorts alone is a challenging path for most niches.

Long-Form Videos: Building Depth and Sustainable Income

Traditional long-form YouTube videos (typically over 60 seconds, but often several minutes or longer) remain the backbone of the platform for many creators and offer distinct advantages, especially if your long-term goal is full-time content creation:

• Higher Monetization Potential: Long-form videos are where the majority of AdSense revenue is generated. The ability to include multiple ad breaks (mid-rolls) significantly increases your earning potential compared to Shorts. Long-form content is also generally better suited for integrating brand partnerships and driving conversions for your own products or services.
• Building Deeper Connections: Longer videos allow you to delve deeper into topics, tell more complex stories, and showcase more of your personality. This helps build a stronger connection with your audience, fostering a more loyal and engaged community.
• Demonstrating Expertise: If your channel is focused on education, tutorials, reviews, or detailed analysis, long-form is the ideal format to demonstrate your knowledge and provide comprehensive value. Channels like @TechWithTim (1.26M subscribers) build their audience on the depth and quality of their programming tutorials, which naturally require longer formats.
• Better for Evergreen Content: In-depth, valuable long-form videos are more likely to be discovered through search and recommended over time, providing consistent views and growth long after they are published.

The primary downsides of starting with long-form content for new creators are:

• Higher Production Effort: Long-form videos require significantly more time, planning, filming, and editing compared to Shorts. This can be a major hurdle if you're balancing YouTube with other commitments.
• Slower Initial Growth: It can take longer for the algorithm to find the right audience for your long-form content, and growth may feel slower compared to the rapid bursts possible with Shorts. Unlocking successful long-form formats often requires more experimentation and patience.
• Greater Risk Per Video: Because you invest more time into each long-form video, a video that doesn't perform well can feel more discouraging than a Short that flops.

How long should YouTube videos be for beginners? There's no magic number, but focus on the length required to deliver value and cover your topic effectively. Don't pad videos to hit an arbitrary length. For beginners, starting with videos in the 5-10 minute range is often manageable and allows enough time to provide substance without requiring massive production efforts. As you get more comfortable, you can explore longer formats if your content demands it.

The Audience Question: Are Your Shorts Viewers the Same as Your Long-Form Viewers?

This is a critical consideration often overlooked by new creators. As highlighted by YouTube strategists, the audience for Shorts and long-form content can be quite different. A Shorts viewer is often passively scrolling, looking for quick entertainment. A long-form viewer is typically actively searching for specific information, entertainment, or a deeper dive into a topic.

Do Shorts help long videos? Generally, no, not directly in terms of converting Shorts viewers into loyal long-form viewers. While Shorts can drive subscribers, those subscribers may not click on your long-form content. If the audience for your Shorts is fundamentally different from the audience that would watch your long-form videos, trying to serve both on the same channel can be detrimental. The low watch time from Shorts-acquired subscribers on your long-form content can signal to the algorithm that your long-form isn't engaging, hindering its reach.

For creators wanting to explore both formats, a more effective strategy might be to create separate channels – one for Shorts and one for long-form – if the content and target audience for each format are distinct. This allows each channel to build its own dedicated audience without negatively impacting the other.

Choosing Your Path: Shorts First, Long Form First, or Both?

So, what's the best approach for your new channel? Consider your goals and capacity:

1. Goal: Rapid Subscriber Growth & Experimentation: If your primary focus is to gain subscribers quickly, test content ideas with minimal effort, and build initial momentum, starting with YouTube Shorts makes sense. Commit to creating and publishing Shorts frequently for a set period (e.g., 60 days) to learn what works. Be aware of the monetization limitations and the potential challenge of transitioning this audience to long-form later.
2. Goal: Sustainable Income & In-Depth Content: If your goal is to build a long-term, monetizable channel with rich, detailed content and you have the capacity for higher production effort, focus on Long-Form Videos from the start. Master this format, build a dedicated audience for it, and benefit from the higher earning potential.
3. Goal: Explore Both (Carefully): If you have the capacity and believe your audience might genuinely consume both, you could try incorporating both from the beginning. However, many experts recommend focusing on mastering one format first before introducing the other. This allows you to dedicate your energy and learn what works best without splitting your focus. If you do both, consider whether your Shorts can effectively serve as trailers, highlights, or complementary content for your long-form videos, and monitor your audience analytics closely to see if there's overlap. If the audiences are distinct, separate channels might be necessary down the line.

Think of it as a "Choose Your Own Adventure." There's no single path, and you can always adapt as you go. The key is to commit to one strategy initially to give it a real chance to work and learn from your results.

Leveraging Tools for Decision Making and Growth

Regardless of which format you choose, using the right tools can help you plan, create, and analyze your content effectively.

Tools like Subscribr can be invaluable for new creators navigating these decisions. Subscribr's Research Assistant can help you analyze successful channels and videos in your potential niche to see what formats are working for others. You can import transcripts of successful videos (both Shorts and long-form) to understand their structure and hooks.

Once you start creating, Subscribr's Script Building Pipeline can streamline the content creation process, whether you're outlining a Short or writing a detailed long-form script. You can use Voice Profiles to ensure consistency and the Hook Creation Tools to grab attention quickly – crucial for both formats!

As you publish, regularly check your YouTube Studio analytics to see how your videos are performing. Pay attention to metrics like average view duration (critical for long-form) and watch time percentage (important for Shorts). Tools like Subscribr's Channel Intelligence can help you analyze your performance metrics, including velocity scoring and outlier scores, to identify what's resonating with your audience and refine your strategy.

By analyzing your own data and understanding what works in your niche using tools like Subscribr, you can make data-driven decisions about your content strategy and ensure you're building a channel that aligns with your goals.

Conclusion

Deciding whether to start with YouTube Shorts, long-form videos, or both is a fundamental strategic choice for any new creator. Shorts offer a faster path to initial discoverability and subscriber growth with lower production effort, but come with monetization challenges and potential audience mismatch. Long-form videos provide greater monetization potential, allow for deeper content, and build stronger audience connections, but require more effort and may see slower initial growth.

Focus on your primary goal: Is it rapid subscriber count, or building a sustainable income stream? Start by mastering the format that best aligns with that goal and your current capacity. Don't feel pressured to do everything at once. Use tools like Subscribr, YouTube Studio, and YouTube Analytics to research your niche, plan your content, and track your performance.

By making a strategic choice upfront and committing to it, you'll build momentum and gain clarity, overcoming those initial feelings of overwhelm and setting your new channel on the right path. Good luck!