Ready to get your next 10,000 subscribers?
Join thousands of creators who use Subscribr to create faster, better YouTube videos.
YouTube Shorts: Separate Channel or Main Channel? (The Right Choice)
One of the biggest questions swirling in the minds of YouTube creators right now is: should I put my new YouTube Shorts on my existing main channel, or should I create a completely separate channel just for Shorts?
It's a valid concern. You've worked hard to build your main channel, cultivate an audience, and establish your long-form content strategy. The last thing you want is for a new format to derail your progress or confuse your loyal subscribers.
Many creators worry that posting Shorts on their main channel will:
- Negatively impact their main channel algorithm: Will the different audience behavior on Shorts (quick views, less watch time per video) somehow mess up the algorithm's understanding of their long-form content and audience?
- Dilute their channel's niche: If Shorts cover slightly different topics or a different style, will it confuse subscribers who came for a specific type of long-form video?
- Make it harder to convert viewers: How do you turn someone who watched a 30-second Short into a dedicated subscriber who watches 10-minute videos?
These are important questions, and the decision isn't one-size-fits-all. However, based on insights from YouTube experts and the platform's direction, there's a clear recommendation for most creators.
Let's break down the pros and cons of each approach and help you make the best decision for your YouTube journey.
Understanding YouTube's Vision for Shorts
Before diving into channel strategy, it's crucial to understand how YouTube sees Shorts fitting into the ecosystem. YouTube is heavily invested in the success of Shorts as a way to compete in the short-form video space. They are giving Shorts significant visibility on the platform, particularly on the mobile homepage and in the dedicated Shorts feed.
Critically, YouTube's stated goal and the direction of the platform's development is to support creators publishing both short-form and long-form content on the same channel. The platform is working to improve the integration so that both formats can thrive together and even complement each other.
Experts in the YouTube space, like those at Think Media, strongly advise against creating a separate channel solely for Shorts in most cases. While the intense focus on Shorts might temporarily shift viewing patterns or impact metrics like average view duration on the channel level, the platform's intention is for creators to use a single channel for all their content.
The key takeaway here is that YouTube wants you to put Shorts on your main channel and is building the platform to support this.
Option 1: Posting Shorts on Your Main Channel
For the vast majority of creators, posting Shorts on your main channel is the recommended strategy.
Pros:
- Simplified Management: Running one channel is significantly easier than managing two. You have one content calendar, one analytics dashboard, and one community to engage with. Managing a second channel effectively requires double the effort.
- Leverage Your Existing Audience: You already have subscribers on your main channel. When you post a Short, it has the potential to be seen by this existing, engaged audience, giving it an initial boost.
- Cross-Promotion Opportunities: This is a major advantage. Shorts can serve as powerful discovery tools that lead viewers to your longer videos, and vice versa. You can use Shorts to tease upcoming long-form content, highlight key moments from past videos, or explore related topics.
- Consolidated Analytics: All your performance data lives in one place in YouTube Studio, allowing you to see how different content formats contribute to your overall channel growth and audience behavior.
- Platform Alignment: As mentioned, YouTube is optimizing for a single-channel approach. Aligning with the platform's direction is generally a good strategy for discoverability and growth.
Cons:
- Potential Perceived Impact on Average View Duration (AVD): Because Shorts are so short, adding them to a channel with long-form content will naturally decrease the overall average view duration for the channel. However, experts agree that this channel-level metric decreasing does not negatively impact the performance or discoverability of your individual long-form videos. YouTube's algorithm evaluates content on a video-by-video basis and understands the difference between Shorts and long-form.
- Audience Confusion (If Content is Off-Brand): This is the most significant potential drawback. If your Shorts are completely unrelated to the core topic or "promise" of your main channel, they can confuse both your audience and the algorithm.
Option 2: Creating a Separate Channel for Shorts
Creating a separate channel specifically for Shorts is rarely the best option, but there are limited scenarios where it might be considered.
Pros:
- Clearer Niche (Potentially): If your idea for Shorts is drastically different from your long-form content, a separate channel could theoretically keep the content streams distinct.
- No Risk of Confusing Main Audience (If Content is Radically Different): If you want to experiment with a completely new topic or style that would truly alienate your main audience, a separate channel could be a way to do it without impacting your primary brand.
Cons:
- Significantly More Work: You now have two channels to manage, two content strategies, two communities, and two sets of analytics. This is a massive time commitment.
- Splitting Your Audience: Instead of building one strong community, you're trying to build two. Viewers who find your Shorts on the separate channel might never discover your main long-form content, and vice versa.
- Lost Cross-Promotion Benefits: You lose the natural ability to funnel viewers between your short-form and long-form content.
- Less Platform Support (Likely): Since YouTube is pushing for a single-channel strategy, separate Shorts-only channels may not receive the same level of integrated support and discoverability features in the long run.
- Difficulty Converting Viewers to Long-Form: It's harder to convert a Shorts viewer to a long-form viewer when they have to leave one channel and go find another.
The Critical Factor: Content Alignment
The decision of where to post your Shorts hinges almost entirely on one question: Does your Shorts content align with the core promise and value proposition of your main channel?
Think about why people subscribed to your main channel in the first place. What kind of value do they expect to receive? What topic are you known for?
- If your main channel is about cooking tutorials, Shorts featuring quick cooking tips, ingredient spotlights, or behind-the-scenes kitchen hacks are a perfect fit. They align with your core promise.
- If your main channel is about in-depth tech reviews, Shorts showcasing quick tech tips, unboxing snippets, or reactions to tech news also align.
- If your main channel is about personal finance, Shorts offering quick budgeting tips, explaining financial terms, or reacting to money news fit well.
In these cases, the Shorts content is "on brand" and "on promise." It serves the same audience with relevant, albeit shorter, content. Posting these Shorts on your main channel makes sense because they reinforce your channel's identity and offer additional value to your existing subscribers, while also attracting new viewers interested in that topic.
However, if your main channel is about cooking, and you suddenly start posting Shorts of your cat doing funny things, that content is not aligned. It doesn't deliver the value your cooking audience subscribed for and will likely confuse them and the algorithm. In this specific, rare scenario, a separate channel might be considered, but even then, the challenges of managing two channels often outweigh the benefits. A better approach might be to integrate slightly different, but still relevant, Short formats (e.g., quick vlogs related to your cooking journey).
As YouTube expert Marcus Jones notes, everything on your channel should be treated as an experiment. Post Shorts that you believe align with your brand on your main channel, analyze the data in YouTube Studio, and see how your audience responds.
Addressing Pain Points & Converting Shorts Viewers
Let's revisit the pain points and how to address them within a single-channel strategy:
- Will Shorts hurt my main channel algorithm? Based on expert analysis, no. While the channel's overall AVD might decrease, YouTube's algorithm evaluates content on a video-by-video basis. A successful Short will be promoted as a Short, and a successful long-form video will be promoted as long-form. The formats are largely separate in terms of how they are recommended, although a viewer discovering you via a Short might then be recommended your long-form content.
- Can I move Shorts to a new channel? Technically, yes, you could delete Shorts from your main channel and re-upload them elsewhere, but this is not recommended. You would lose any existing views and engagement on those Shorts, and it's a cumbersome process. It's better to make the right decision upfront and stick with it.
- Difficulty in converting Shorts viewers into loyal subscribers for long-form content. This is a valid challenge, as Shorts viewers have different consumption habits. However, it's not impossible. Here's how to approach it:
- Strong Calls to Action (CTAs): In your Shorts, verbally and visually include CTAs directing viewers to your long-form content. Mention specific related videos or encourage them to check out your channel for more in-depth content.
- Link in Comments/Description: While links in the Shorts description aren't clickable within the Shorts feed, you can direct viewers to a link in the pinned comment or your channel page.
- Content Strategy Integration: Create Shorts that directly relate to or tease your long-form videos. Use a Short to show an exciting result from a long-form tutorial, or address a common question that's answered in more detail in a longer video.
- Branding Consistency: Maintain consistent branding (logos, colors, music style where appropriate) between your Shorts and long-form content so viewers recognize your channel.
- Channel Trailer/Featured Video: Ensure your channel page is optimized with a compelling trailer and featured videos that showcase your best long-form content to Shorts viewers who click through.
Making the Right Choice for YOU
Ultimately, the decision comes down to your content, your audience, and your capacity to manage your channel.
- For established long-form YouTubers: If your planned Shorts content aligns with your existing channel's topic and audience expectations, put them on your main channel. Leverage your existing subscriber base and the potential for cross-promotion. Don't be overly concerned about the channel-level AVD metric; focus on individual video performance and overall subscriber growth.
- For new creators planning their strategy: Unless you have a very specific, niche idea for Shorts that is radically different from any long-form content you ever plan to make, start with one channel. It's much easier to build momentum and manage your content when it's all in one place. You can always experiment with different Short formats within that single channel.
Managing your YouTube strategy, whether you're focusing on Shorts, long-form, or both, requires careful planning and analysis. Optimizing your channel structure for a better audience experience and growth directly impacts your potential for monetization down the line, as a cohesive strategy leads to more engaged viewers and subscribers.
Tools & Resources
Making strategic decisions about your content and analyzing performance is key to growth. Tools can help you understand your audience, analyze what's working, and plan your content effectively.
Subscribr is a comprehensive AI-powered platform built specifically for YouTube creators. You can use Subscribr's Channel Intelligence system to analyze your existing channel's performance and audience, helping you understand if your Shorts ideas align. The Audience Persona Generation feature can provide insights into who your target viewers are, ensuring your Shorts resonate. When planning your content, Subscribr's Script Building Pipeline can help you outline and write both your long-form videos and your Shorts, ensuring consistency in messaging and branding. Finally, you can use Subscribr's Video Performance Intelligence to analyze how your individual Shorts and long-form videos are performing and identify patterns in successful content using features like Outlier Score calculation.
Conclusion
For most YouTube creators, the answer to the "separate channel or main channel" question for Shorts is clear: put them on your main channel. This simplifies management, leverages your existing audience, and aligns with YouTube's platform development. The key is ensuring your Shorts content is relevant and valuable to the audience you've built (or are building) on that channel. Focus on integrating Shorts strategically with your long-form content and using clear calls to action to guide viewers towards becoming loyal, dedicated subscribers.
