Can You REALLY Grow a Channel Using ONLY YouTube Shorts?

Ready to get your next 10,000 subscribers?

Join thousands of creators who use Subscribr to create faster, better YouTube videos.

Free trial No credit card required

Can You REALLY Grow a Channel Using ONLY YouTube Shorts? (And Should You?)

Aspiring YouTubers often wonder if the explosive popularity of YouTube Shorts offers a shortcut to channel growth. The idea of viral Shorts bringing in subscribers by the thousands is tempting, especially when compared to the effort required for long-form videos. But can you really build a sustainable, successful channel relying solely on Shorts? And what are the hidden challenges?

This article dives deep into the viability of a Shorts-exclusive strategy, exploring the potential for rapid growth alongside the significant downsides and offering actionable insights for new creators navigating the short-form landscape in 2025.

The Allure of Shorts: Rapid Growth and Virality

There's no denying the power of YouTube Shorts for generating massive views and attracting subscribers quickly. YouTube is heavily promoting the format to compete with other short-form platforms, and the algorithm can push successful Shorts to enormous audiences.

We see channels gaining significant traction with short-form content. While not exclusively Shorts-only, channels like @screamstream7 (322K subscribers) in the wilderness survival niche have shown impressive recent view velocity, indicating strong performance with shorter content formats. Similarly, gaming clip channels like @alloftheclips (233K subscribers) and @AiClipssssss (111K subscribers) demonstrate high Views-to-Subscriber ratios, suggesting their short-form content is highly consumable and engaging.

The youtube_strategy tool confirms this potential, highlighting that Shorts can drive "massive views and subscriber growth quickly," with some new channels gaining "tens of thousands of subscribers and millions of views in just weeks." This rapid exposure is the primary draw for creators starting out.

Videos like "SATISFYING Sounds Using LEGO..." by @TD BRICKS, with over 76 million views, or various "quick cooking hacks" Shorts from channels like @Joshua Weissman and @PONGAMOSLO A PRUEBA CORTOS, consistently racking up millions of views (e.g., "Food HACKS I Learned In Restaurants" with over 13 million views), prove the format's capability for viral reach. Content that is visually satisfying, provides quick value (like a hack), or is inherently entertaining performs exceptionally well.

However, focusing solely on this rapid subscriber gain overlooks crucial aspects of building a truly successful and sustainable YouTube presence.

The Downsides of a Shorts-Only Channel

While subscriber counts might soar, a Shorts-only strategy comes with significant limitations and can lead to frustrating challenges for creators focused on long-term channel health and monetization.

One of the major pain points for creators is the difficulty in converting Shorts viewers into loyal subscribers for long-form content. The youtube_strategy tool points out that the "Shorts audience is distinct from the long-form audience." Viewers scrolling the Shorts shelf are often in a different mindset than those seeking out longer videos. They are looking for quick entertainment or information, not necessarily a deep dive or a connection with a creator. This means subscribers gained from Shorts may have little interest in watching your longer videos, leading to low long-form viewership despite a high subscriber count.

Another critical downside is limited monetization directly from the Shorts shelf. As highlighted by the youtube_strategy tool, Shorts currently "are not directly monetized via Adsense when watched on the Shorts shelf." While there is a Shorts Fund and revenue sharing is being introduced, the RPM (Revenue Per Mille views) is significantly lower compared to long-form content. This makes it challenging to generate substantial income purely from video views on a Shorts-only channel.

Furthermore, some creators report concerns about Shorts negatively impacting their main long-form content channel if the audiences for the two formats don't align. The algorithm might struggle to understand your channel's core audience if you're attracting viewers with vastly different interests through Shorts and long-form, potentially hurting the performance of your longer videos.

The youtube_strategy insights emphasize this: "If the Shorts attract a different type of viewer than the long-form content is designed for, the subscribers gained from Shorts will not watch the long videos, leading to low long-form viewership despite a high subscriber count."

In essence, while Shorts can give you a large number on your subscriber count, they don't automatically translate into a deeply engaged community or significant ad revenue.

How to Monetize a Shorts-Only Channel

Given the limitations of direct monetization via the Shorts shelf, creators focusing on Shorts need to explore alternative revenue streams. A Shorts-only channel primarily builds influence and reach, which can then be leveraged for income.

Here are the key ways to monetize a channel built on Shorts:

1. Brand Deals and Sponsorships: As your view counts and subscriber numbers grow, even with Shorts, you become attractive to brands. Companies are willing to pay creators to feature their products or services in their content. The high view counts Shorts can generate make them a compelling platform for brand promotion.
2. Affiliate Marketing: Promote products or services you use and trust by including affiliate links in your Shorts descriptions or comments (pinning a comment is effective). You earn a commission on any sales made through your unique link.
3. Selling Your Own Products or Services: Use Shorts to drive traffic to your own offerings, such as merchandise, digital products (ebooks, courses), coaching, or services. Shorts can act as quick, engaging advertisements for your business.
4. Patreon or Memberships: Build a community around your content and offer exclusive perks to members or patrons who support you financially. While converting Shorts viewers to dedicated community members can be challenging, it's possible with a strong personality and consistent value.
5. Directing Traffic Off-Platform: Use Shorts to encourage viewers to visit your website, email list, or other social media platforms where you might have more direct monetization options or deeper audience engagement.

It's crucial to understand that this requires a shift in mindset. You're not just monetizing views; you're monetizing the attention and influence your Shorts generate.

The Conversion Challenge: Turning Shorts Viewers into Long-Form Fans

One of the most significant hurdles for creators using Shorts is bridging the gap between the short-form audience and the long-form content. If your goal is eventually to create longer videos, you need a strategy to encourage crossover.

The core principle, as emphasized by the youtube_strategy tool, is to attract the exact same audience with both formats. This means your Shorts shouldn't just be broadly related to your niche; they should appeal to the specific type of viewer who would also enjoy your long-form content. For example, if your long-form videos are in-depth tutorials on advanced woodworking, your Shorts should showcase quick tips or satisfying moments that appeal to someone interested in advanced woodworking, not just general DIY.

Strategies to encourage conversion:

• Use Shorts as Teasers or Highlights: Create Shorts that are compelling snippets or previews of your longer videos. This gives viewers a taste of the in-depth content and encourages them to click through for more. The youtube_strategy tool suggests using Shorts as "previews for your longer videos by adding an end card linking to the full-length content."
• Strategic Call-to-Actions (CTAs): Don't just hope viewers will find your long-form content. Include clear, concise verbal CTAs within your Shorts, on-screen text, and in the description or pinned comment directing viewers to your related long-form video or channel page.
• Link Features: Utilize YouTube's features that allow linking from Shorts to related long-form videos. Make it as easy as possible for interested viewers to make the jump.
• Plan Shorts Around Long-Form Content: Instead of creating Shorts in isolation, integrate them into your content calendar. When planning a long-form video, brainstorm several Short ideas related to that topic. Release these Shorts before, during, or after the long-form video to create a content ecosystem that funnels viewers towards your main content. The youtube_strategy tool highlights this as an effective "Integration Strategy."
• Optimize Your Channel Page: Ensure your channel homepage is well-organized and clearly showcases your long-form content so that viewers who land there from a Short can easily find more of what they might like.

It's a continuous process of experimentation to see what resonates and effectively guides viewers from the fast-paced Shorts environment to the more engaged space of long-form video.

The Separate Channel Debate: Mixing vs. Specializing

A common question among creators is whether to post Shorts on their main channel alongside long-form videos or create a dedicated Shorts channel. Both approaches have potential benefits and drawbacks.

The youtube_strategy tool notes that YouTube Shorts are a "highly polarizing feature," with some creators reporting "negative impacts on their long-form content" when mixing formats. This concern stems from the idea that attracting a large Shorts audience with different viewing habits might dilute your main channel's audience signals, potentially confusing the algorithm and hurting the reach of your long-form videos.

Creating a Separate Shorts Channel:

• Pros: Keeps audience signals distinct, allowing the algorithm to better understand the target audience for each format. This can prevent a mismatch where Shorts viewers are recommended long-form content they won't watch, and vice-versa. It allows for different branding and content styles tailored specifically to the short-form format.
• Cons: Requires managing two separate channels, which doubles the workload. Building an audience on a new channel takes time and effort.

The youtube_strategy tool shares a compelling case study of a creator who successfully grew both a long-form Pokemon channel (@DeepPocketMonster, 1.5M+ subs) and a separate Shorts Pokemon channel (@ShortPocketMonster, 1.3M+ subs, 2B+ views). The key was that the audiences for their long-form "movie" style videos and their short-form "show" episodes were distinct, making separate channels a more effective strategy.

Mixing Shorts and Long-Form on One Channel:

• Pros: Simpler management, potential for some audience crossover, can introduce your existing long-form audience to your Shorts and vice-versa.
• Cons: Risk of audience mismatch and potential negative impact on long-form performance if the Shorts audience isn't interested in longer content. Requires a cohesive content strategy where both formats target a similar viewer profile.

The youtube_strategy tool suggests that mixing can work "If the audience for shorts and long form content is the same," such as chopping up long-form video podcasts into short clips.

Ultimately, the decision depends on your specific content, target audience, and goals. If your Shorts and long-form content appeal to very different viewers, separate channels might be safer. If they target the same specific audience, mixing might work, but careful monitoring of analytics is essential. Experimentation is key, and the youtube_strategy tool advises focusing on mastering one format first before attempting both.

Crafting Compelling YouTube Shorts

Regardless of whether you go Shorts-only or integrate, creating engaging Shorts is paramount for any success in the format. Shorts thrive on immediacy, visual appeal, and strong hooks.

• Native vs. Repurposed: While you can repurpose clips from long-form, creating content specifically for the vertical Shorts format often performs better. Think visually, grab attention instantly, and deliver value or entertainment quickly.
• The Hook is Everything: The first few seconds are critical. You need to immediately hook the viewer and make them want to keep watching. This could be a surprising visual, a bold statement, or a compelling question.
• Keep it Concise (Mostly): While Shorts can now be up to 3 minutes, the most viral often remain under 60 seconds. Deliver your core message or entertainment quickly.
• Leverage Trends: Pay attention to trending sounds, challenges, and formats on YouTube and other short-form platforms. Find ways to creatively participate in trends while tying them back to your niche, as suggested by the youtube_strategy tool.
• Focus on Satisfying or Valuable Content: Look at successful Shorts examples from our search. Shorts like "The Peel Is WOW!!" by @TJShorts and "Have you ever tried scrape art??" by @Yasmin The Art Person leverage satisfying visuals. Cooking hacks from @Joshua Weissman and @PONGAMOSLO A PRUEBA CORTOS provide quick, actionable value. Consider what visual, auditory, or informational value you can deliver in under a minute.

Tools & Resources for Your Shorts Strategy

Navigating the world of YouTube Shorts requires understanding performance and planning content effectively. Tools designed for YouTube creators can provide valuable insights.

Understanding what makes your Shorts perform requires analyzing data. Subscribr's Channel Intelligence system can help you analyze your Shorts' performance metrics, including view counts and engagement. While the outlier score is primarily designed for long-form, tracking overall view velocity and identifying which Shorts gain the most traction can inform your content strategy.

To find inspiration and understand what's working in your niche, Subscribr's Research Assistant can be invaluable. You can use it to analyze successful Shorts from other creators by importing transcripts or analyzing video data, helping you identify popular topics, formats, and hooks. Subscribr's Competitive Analysis features allow you to study top-performing Shorts channels and videos to uncover patterns and strategies you can adapt.

When it comes to planning and scripting your Shorts, Subscribr's AI Script Writer and content planning tools can streamline the process. You can use the research gathered to quickly generate outlines and drafts tailored for the short-form format, ensuring your content is concise and engaging.

By using these tools to research successful examples, analyze your own performance, and plan your content strategically, you can make data-driven decisions about your Shorts strategy.

Conclusion: A Shorts-Only Channel Can Grow, But Strategic Integration is Key

So, can you REALLY grow a channel using ONLY YouTube Shorts?

Yes, you can absolutely grow your subscriber count significantly and often rapidly with a Shorts-only strategy. The platform's push for short-form content offers unprecedented reach.

However, a Shorts-only approach is often limited in terms of monetization directly from views and building a deeply engaged community that will follow you to other content formats or platforms. The audience acquired through Shorts may be primarily interested in quick, snackable content and may not convert easily into loyal viewers for long-form videos.

For most creators aiming for a sustainable, long-term YouTube career with diverse monetization options, the most effective approach isn't Shorts-only, but rather strategic integration of Shorts into a broader channel strategy.

Focus on creating Shorts that appeal to the same specific audience as your long-form content. Use Shorts as a powerful discovery tool and a way to funnel viewers towards your longer videos, where you can build deeper connections and access more lucrative monetization methods. Experiment with mixing formats on one channel or using separate channels if your audiences are distinct.

Growth on YouTube, whether through Shorts or long-form, requires understanding your audience, creating compelling content, and adapting your strategy based on real data. By leveraging the reach of Shorts strategically and combining it with a plan for audience engagement and monetization beyond just views, you can build a truly successful YouTube channel. Experiment, analyze, and refine your approach – that's the key to thriving in the evolving YouTube landscape.